Sign in
Centerville Pie Co.
About
- 3.8 ( 16 reviews)
- $$, $$$
The Centerville Pie Company is a Massachusetts-based pie company located on Cape Cod. Founded in 2009 by long-time friends Laurie Bowen and Kristin Broadley (“The Pie Ladies”), the local pie shop was thrust into the national spotlight shortly after they opened their doors when they were discovered by Oprah Winfrey. Our Pie Shop is open Monday - Saturday 8am-6pm and Sunday 9am to 3pm. We have and delicious selection of fresh-baked savory meat pies, fruit pies, cream pies and quiche pies. Also our freezer is stocked with pies to take home and bake. We also have prepared lunches, dinners, and soups to heat up at home.
| Day of the Week | Opening Hours |
|---|---|
| Monday | 8:00 - 18:00 |
| Tuesday | 8:00 - 18:00 |
| Wednesday | 8:00 - 18:00 |
| Thursday | 8:00 - 18:00 |
| Friday | 8:00 - 18:00 |
| Saturday | Closed |
| Sunday | Closed |
Cuisines
- 🍔 American
Dining Options
- ♿ Wheelchair Accessible
- 🥡 Takeout
- 🅿️ Parking Available
- 💳 Accepts Credit Cards
- 💳 Accepts Visa
- 💳 Accepts Mastercard
- 💳 Accepts American Express
- 💳 Accepts Discover
Accepts Credit Cards
Recommended Reviews
3.8
Joan Hofer
Bought and baked according to directions..am sad to say it wasnt very good meat wise..the chicken was not easy chewable..dry, mealy like and hard to chew...ended up tossing it in the garbage.$9.00+ wasted...wont purchase this again.
Mandy Rivett
I have always loved the chicken pot pies! Last night we decided to switch it up and went with a beef shepards pie and it was fantastic! I also grabbed a few ice cream sandwiches and they were so great and my family loved them so much that I went back for more today. They have a few different kinds, we went with chocolate chip and sugar cookie. Hands down the best we've had! I personally recommend the sugar cookie ones!
Fat Louie
Bought in my local supermarket in Long Island, NY. Was good. What would have made it great was including a small ketchup sized pack of gravy, which is pretty tasty. I'd definitely buy them again if they add the gravy. My son said the same thing. They definitely have a good product and if I lived near their store I'd go there.. and of course, ask for gravy. Lol
Thomas Waelter
I have tried many times to contact your company via email for a price list of your product, with no response.I'm asking, because I paid $60.00 for four individual pies and two small containers of gravy. My experience cooking them in a Frigidaire stove, following your directions, with poor results. The dough remains under cooked, chicken is stringy, and the sauce has the consistency of wall paper paste .Overall, over priced and poor quality.👎
Kris Dugan
I read on their website that they closed the cafe section, boo. It was nice to be able to go in and get a meal and slice of pie, if buying a whole pie is Impractical for you. They have fresh pies available as well as Frozen , that you make yourself at home. See you can bring home a peach pie and keep it in the freezer until Thanksgiving
Judy Antico
I purchased a frozen Chicken Pot Pie with vegetables. Flavor was good and pastry was excellent. I was disappointed that there was very little gravy and what there was was gluey. Some of the pieces of chicken were so large you had to cut them up.
Yvonne Noiles
Every Sept. I drive down to Centerville Pie Company for my chicken pie fix. I usually buy a couple for my freezer. They are a great go to meal on a cold winters day when you need some comfort food. Yes the gravy is a little salty, but I just don't put any salt in my mashed potato when I cook the pie. Love that pie.
Sam Dryhill
Saw the mini breakfast pies at a grocery store. Was excited thinking they would be an awesome quick breakfast. Have never tried other styles of this companies pies so I can not comment on those, but these mini breakfast pies. There are deserts in the Middle East that have more moisture than the crust of these pies. Filling is fine but GD the crust is so dry it practically crumbled and turned to dust when I picked it up. It’s been three days and I’m still drinking fluids to replace the saliva this stupid pie drained from my mouth. Good lord.
Heidi Jacobe
This is a must-visit if you're a pie lover. They have a very large selection of both sweet and savory pies - frozen, refrigerated, and room temperature. All are homemade, on the premises. I've stopped making pies for holiday dinners, as I can get as-good or even better ones here. The staff and owners are consistently pleasant, upbeat and friendly, and they will bend over backwards to ensure that you leave their store a happy, and permanent customer.
Paul J Park
I love this place! Can't wait until we go back for more pies!
Greg Selivon
Never had the pleasure of visiting the actual store, so this review is based solely on our purchase of their shepherds pie from our local supermarket -----------------------------------------------Delicious ----------------peace #greggace
Chris Fortin
Had the buffalo chicken pies today the first one was good but the second one was really dry. I can't respond to the owner so I'll update my review. I appreciate the prompt response and appreciate the gesture. I don't live in the area but thank you anyways
Paul Wingert
Just had to write a review to let folks know how great these pies are. We live in Texas and had two fantastic pies. They arrived in great shape and are easy to prepare for a special occasion or they would make a great gift.
Nick Tomlinson
Went here with my brother, sister, and cousin. The breakfast was amazing. I had a lobster benedict which was to die for. Then we had dessert pies. I live in Florida but there Key Lime pie is perhaps the best that I've had. I had the chocolate bread pudding which was great. Donna was our server... she was fantastic!
Chris Elmer
Everything I have tried from here has been great.
Mary Anne Coburn
OUTSTANDING chicken pot pie!! It tastes exactly what my mother made when growing up and trust me I tried making it and it didn’t come close to your pie. My husband bought this as he has with many other local pies and we both agreed best pie we,ve purchased. I went on line to see what else you sold, read other reviews and shocked at complaints the chicken pieces were to large? What pie do you buy that has large chunks of chicken, veggies and so tasty! Perfect for a cold night, just delicious. The owner has a big heart, helping your community and your disabled employees supports is the best reward as we all know giving back to others it doesn’t get better! Thank you ðŸ˜ðŸ‘ðŸ‘🙂