Centerville Pie Co.

About

3.8 ( 16 reviews)
$$, $$$

The Centerville Pie Company is a Massachusetts-based pie company located on Cape Cod. Founded in 2009 by long-time friends Laurie Bowen and Kristin Broadley (“The Pie Ladies”), the local pie shop was thrust into the national spotlight shortly after they opened their doors when they were discovered by Oprah Winfrey. Our Pie Shop is open Monday - Saturday 8am-6pm and Sunday 9am to 3pm. We have and delicious selection of fresh-baked savory meat pies, fruit pies, cream pies and quiche pies. Also our freezer is stocked with pies to take home and bake. We also have prepared lunches, dinners, and soups to heat up at home.

Day of the Week	Opening Hours
Monday	8:00 - 18:00
Tuesday	8:00 - 18:00
Wednesday	8:00 - 18:00
Thursday	8:00 - 18:00
Friday	8:00 - 18:00
Saturday	Closed
Sunday	Closed

Cuisines

🍔 American

Dining Options

♿ Wheelchair Accessible
🥡 Takeout
🅿️ Parking Available
💳 Accepts Credit Cards
💳 Accepts Visa
💳 Accepts Mastercard
💳 Accepts American Express
💳 Accepts Discover

Accepts Credit Cards

Recommended Reviews

56%

12%

18%

3.8

16 reviews

Add review

😕

Joan Hofer

2018-11-15 on google

Bought and baked according to directions..am sad to say it wasnt very good meat wise..the chicken was not easy chewable..dry, mealy like and hard to chew...ended up tossing it in the garbage.$9.00+ wasted...wont purchase this again.

😍

Mandy Rivett

2018-07-22 on google

I have always loved the chicken pot pies! Last night we decided to switch it up and went with a beef shepards pie and it was fantastic! I also grabbed a few ice cream sandwiches and they were so great and my family loved them so much that I went back for more today. They have a few different kinds, we went with chocolate chip and sugar cookie. Hands down the best we've had! I personally recommend the sugar cookie ones!

😀

Fat Louie

2018-06-05 on google

Bought in my local supermarket in Long Island, NY. Was good. What would have made it great was including a small ketchup sized pack of gravy, which is pretty tasty. I'd definitely buy them again if they add the gravy. My son said the same thing. They definitely have a good product and if I lived near their store I'd go there.. and of course, ask for gravy. Lol

Add review

More Reviews (16)

Questions & Answers

Ask a Question

We were there today and bought 2 pies at $23 each that feed 6. You could call them to confirm.

Centerville Pies can be kept frozen for up to 1 year. Check the label for the Sell By date. Thank you for your question. Diane Customer Service Centerville Pie Company

I have found the chicken pie in the freezer section of the stop and shop. I haven't tried it yet so not sure if it's the same quality as the ones at the store. When I do buy one I will post a review

We do but it is more of a summer product for us. We are currently out of stock. We do make a nice Clam Pie and a Chourizo, Linguica, and Clam Pie. We carry both in our Pie Shop.

Call them...

Hi Louise, Your most economical way to purchase our pies in through our website: www.centervillepies.com. One pie, including shipping is $64.00. Two pies, shipped is $99.00. You can schedule, on-line - when you would like your pies delivered. We ship Monday, Tuesday, & Wednesday. Hope this is helpful. We look forward to taking your order.

Hi Robert. If you're looking to order online for nationwide shipping, our options and prices can be found here: https://centerville.goldbelly.com/ If you're visiting us in our shop, our prices are: - large savory pies $24 - small savory pies $15 - large fruit and cream pies $20 - small fruit and cream $13 and our in-store menu can be found here: https://www.centervillepies.com/pie-menu/

Hi Judy! Hope you got everything you were looking for! With a few hours notice we can have any in stock pie baked and ready to go!

Hi there! We do not deliver from the shop, but if you are not local we do ship pies. More info can be found on our website! https://www.centervillepies.com/